Opens in a new tab

An Unforgettable Experience!

Susan Bowers, now Susan Traficante, reflects on her experience as a 16-year-old youth delegate at Algoma’s 1973 Diocesan Synod, where women’s ordination was debated.

Published on November 10, 2026
A story from the Algoma Anglican archives revisits a memorable experience and offers a glimpse into the Diocese of Algoma’s past.

At 16, Susan Bowers was among the youth delegates calling for women’s ordination at Algoma’s 1973 Diocesan Synod. Fifty-three years later, now Susan Traficante, she reflects on the debate, the generations that shaped it, and the questions the Church is still asking.

One of the things that strikes her most is the distance between the worldviews of those gathered at Synod.

“Many of the male clergy and delegates would actually have been born in the Edwardian age,” she reflected during an October 2026 interview. They were also “children of parents who were very strongly in the Victorian age.”

As a young member of St. Luke’s Cathedral in Sault Ste. Marie, Susan found herself participating in a pivotal debate over whether women should be ordained to the priesthood.

The following January, the Algoma Anglican published her reflections under the headline “An experience I will never forget!”

READ SUSAN BOWERS’ ORIGINAL JANUARY 1974 ARTICLE

More than half a century later, the article offers a glimpse into a young woman’s thinking as Canadian society, and the Church, were reconsidering long-established assumptions about women’s roles. Her reflections today reveal how that debate looks through the experience of someone who witnessed it and lived through the changes that followed.

A meeting of generations

“It was a little bit of an eye opener for me,” Susan recalled.

She remembers the youth delegates sitting together, accompanied by a young curate who joined their discussions. “We had interesting private discussions at our table.” Susan had always considered the Church a welcoming place. “St. Luke’s had been a very nurturing and welcoming environment for me,” she said. “And so, I think there was some eye rolling, when people would actually get up and very powerfully speak against the ordination of women.”

The younger delegates were coming of age amid social changes that challenged the expectations of earlier generations. Susan remembers the Royal Commission on the Status of Women, the growing women’s movement, and public conversations surrounding Gloria Steinem and Germaine Greer.

“It was a very interesting time considering the social changes that were happening,” she said. “And it was only just getting started.”

“It was a glass ceiling”

Susan’s support for the ordination of women had grown from her own experience. “I had some wonderful teachers in high school who were, you know, well educated and could really advocate for equality of women.”

Her mother had worked as the archbishop’s personal secretary before Susan was born and later as secretary to the dean of St. Luke’s Cathedral. Susan also remembered a woman churchwarden who held a senior administrative position at the local hospital.

Yet at St. Luke’s, the choir consisted of men and boys, and the clergy were exclusively male. “It was mystifying to me,” recalled Susan, “that the women of the church were largely responsible for the very crucial domestic duties centred around upkeep and beautification, hospitality, childcare and fundraising, but becoming a lay reader was as close as they could come to ordination. It was a glass ceiling.”

In her January 1974 article, she was unequivocal. “We, the youth delegates of Algoma, were definitely in favour of the ordination of women,” she wrote. “We agreed that any person who feels that he or she has been called to serve the Lord must be able to do so, regardless of sex!”

“When circumstances so require”

The motion before Synod proposed accepting women’s ordination to the priesthood in principle, with its introduction permitted “when circumstances so require.” That qualification troubled the youth delegates. “It was kind of like when the men went to the Second World War. Well, the women were allowed to go and work at the factories.”

Susan remembered their concern that the Church might approve women’s ordination without actually welcoming women into its parishes. “Maybe they would say, yes, women would be ordained, but then no one would want that to happen at their churches.”

The debate was lengthy, with delegates proposing amendments and presenting competing arguments. “I do remember a very protracted amendment process,” she said.

The practical challenges of ministry

Some theological objections struck the young delegates as unconvincing, including arguments based on Jesus having chosen twelve male apostles. “Some of the arguments were more compelling,” Susan reflected.

She remembered concerns about the unpredictable hours of parish ministry and the responsibilities of raising children. “There were certainly not daycare centres at that time. Childcare was difficult,” she said. “There were legitimate concerns about that, I think, because it was a different time. You couldn’t just go out in the middle of the night and leave your children.”

Her recollections invite a distinction between arguments rooted in traditional restrictions and practical questions about sustaining ministry while raising a family. Those questions remain relevant.

In October 2026, Archbishop Anne Germond told the Anglican Journal that a colleague had pointed out that only three priests in Algoma had taken maternity leave over the preceding 50 years. “What is holding back women with young families?” she asked.

The challenge may be to recognize the practical demands of ministry without allowing them to become barriers to vocation, particularly as the Church encourages and supports future generations of clergy.

“We thought, well, that’s it”

When the vote was taken in 1973, the motion passed by 102 votes to 51. “I do remember a sense of jubilation with the people that I was sitting with,” Susan recalled. For the young delegates, the result seemed decisive. “We thought, well, that’s it.”

On November 30, 1976, the Anglican Church of Canada ordained its first six women priests. But Algoma did not ordain its first woman priest until May 16, 1985, when Susan de Gruchy was ordained at St. Michael and All Angels in Thunder Bay.

Susan remembers the intervening years. “We just kept waiting and waiting. We thought that as soon as it was passed, the floodgates would open, things would happen.”

Instead, twelve years passed between the Synod vote and Algoma’s first woman priest. “It did seem to take a long time before there were ordained women clergy in our diocese,” she said.

“I would be thrilled”

Asked how she would feel if she could have looked ahead from 1973 to see what the Church would become, her response was unequivocal. “I would be thrilled, actually, to be able to look into the future and see what has happened, and gratified that I was able to be part of the process here.”

The contrast between the Church she knew in 1973 and the Church of 2026 is remarkable. Women now serve in positions of leadership that would scarcely have seemed imaginable to many delegates gathered at that Synod.

There is something especially valuable about Susan’s perspective at this anniversary.

She remembers the urgency of a younger generation eager to see change. She remembers the profound differences in outlook between those younger delegates and some of the people who opposed women’s ordination. And she can now look back with a generosity of understanding that comes from recognizing how profoundly people are shaped by their time.

The 50th anniversary invites the Church to celebrate much more than a change in its rules. It is an opportunity to give thanks for the courage of the first women priests, the faithfulness of those who supported them, and the generations of women whose ministry has enriched the Church.

It is also an opportunity to acknowledge how our understanding continues to develop—and to ask whether there are barriers today that future generations may look back upon with the same mixture of surprise and determination.

In 1974, Susan Bowers concluded her newspaper reflection by describing the privilege of participating in one of Algoma’s most consequential Synods. At 16, she already knew she had witnessed something important.

Fifty-three years later, Susan Traficante is still helping us understand just how important it was.

“The ordination of Canadian women has allowed the Anglican Church to stay relevant,” says Susan, “in a society that has achieved so much of what we dreamed about as teenagers!”

 

—

From the Archives is a Diocese of Algoma series commemorating the 50th anniversary of the ordination of women to the priesthood in the Anglican Church of Canada.