Opens in a new tab

A Northern Parish Saves Its Church

St James during winter 2025, at the start of their fundraiser.
Published on November 11, 2026

With a historic building nearly lost, the congregation of St. James Anglican Church in Cobalt discovered just how far faith, determination, and a little northern generosity could take them. 

When the congregation of St. James Anglican Church in Cobalt learned in June 2025 that its historic worship space was no longer safe to enter, the news was devastating. 

The building had serious structural problems. The nave was effectively condemned, and parishioners were told they could no longer worship there. 

For the Rev. Valerie Paterson, who serves St. James and St. Paul and St. John in nearby Haileybury, the memory of those first conversations is still vivid. 

“We all sat around shell-shocked, going, ‘Oh my stars, now what are we going to do?’” 

There was no easy answer. The building was more than a century old, the repairs would be extensive, and finding experienced contractors in northern Ontario was no small matter. For a congregation that had once numbered only a handful of people on a Sunday, the challenge could easily have been overwhelming. 

But St. James was not ready to give up. 

“You go or you stop,” Rev. Paterson said, recalling the choice that confronted the parish. 

And they chose to go. 

A little church on top of the hill 

To understand what followed, Paterson says, it helps to understand Cobalt itself. 

Once internationally renowned for its silver mines, the small northern Ontario town has a history and a reach that far exceeds its size. 

“If you check any of the old atlases, any of the old globes, none of the towns in the north are really marked, and Cobalt is this gigantic dot,” she said. “Because it had such a storied history with that silver rush and all that.” 

Those connections, she believes, have helped sustain the restoration campaign. “There’s a lot of people out there that hold Cobalt close to their heart. And when this project came on, little dabs of money were coming from here and there and everywhere.” 

The support has extended well beyond the congregation, although Rev. Val is quick to point out that the church had already begun rebuilding its relationship with the community long before the structural crisis arrived. 

For several years, St. James has operated Soup’s On, a community meal program that has become an important part of life in Cobalt. In a town that has faced its share of economic struggles and closures, the program has done something rather wonderful: it has reminded people that the church is still there. 

“When Soup’s On started, people started saying, ‘Well, where is that?’ It’s a little church on top of the hill, and the next words out of their mouth would be, ‘Oh, I thought that was closed.’” 

Rev. Paterson has watched the congregation grow alongside the ministry. Some newer members include young families who have moved north from southern Ontario in search of affordable housing. Others have found their way to St. James through the church’s increasingly visible presence in the community. 

Paterson sees something larger at work. 

“They themselves, with the extreme help of the Holy Spirit, have generated this little hub of positivity that is kind of like a vortex that draws stuff in towards it because people are so hungry for the positive right now.” 

The work of saving a church 

Once the congregation decided to proceed, the practical work began. 

An engineer was consulted, contractors were considered, and eventually a builder with experience restoring another century-old northern building—the Legion in Haileybury—was hired. 

Much of the work has taken place beneath the church, where deteriorating structural supports had to be removed and replaced. Exterior repairs and work around the foundation were also required. The conditions were hardly ideal. 

“They had to be extremely fit and extremely thin to be able to get in there and pull out those joists and lay in the new ones,” Rev. Val said. And then there was the tree stump. “There was a gigantic tree stump that was still in the ground that they just built the church over top of a hundred years ago. So they had to work around that.” 

The contractors, she says, have done an excellent job. The most urgent structural work has progressed to the point that the engineer has now declared the church safe to re-enter. 

Insulation remains the next major priority. Finding the right person to do the job is also the next major challenge. But after everything the congregation has already overcome, Rev. Paterson is not inclined to lose heart. 

The soup has always been on 

Throughout the restoration, the congregation has continued to worship in its small attached parish hall, a space Paterson estimates is barely 20 feet square, excluding the kitchen. 

There is little room and virtually no storage. On some Sundays, children attending Sunday school have met in a tent outside. 

And yet, despite the construction, Soup’s On has continued. 

“The soup has always been on,” Val said. 

That has required some determined juggling of tables, chairs, supplies, and people. 

Volunteers prepare the hall for Saturday’s community meal, clear everything away, and get it ready again for Sunday worship. The routine repeats every fourth Saturday of the month, with occasional seasonal breaks to give the volunteers a well-earned rest. 

“You can’t work them to the bone,” Rev. Val.  “They’re valuable. They’re like gold.” 

The cramped quarters have done little to dampen the congregation’s spirits. 

On a recent Sunday, Paterson arrived to find the little hall buzzing with conversation and excitement. There was coffee, there were treats, and there was a growing sense that the day everyone had been working toward was finally approaching. “They can feel they’re going to be able to get into the worship area soon.” 

A generosity that keeps spreading 

The fundraising campaign has followed much the same pattern as the congregation’s renewal: an encouraging beginning, followed by an ever-widening circle of support. 

Rev. Paterson describes it as a pebble dropped into a pond. 

“You’ve got the initial from the church itself, and then it just started to circle out from there.” Some gifts have come through familiar channels, including diocesan support. Others have arrived in wonderfully unexpected ways. 

At church one recent Sunday, a parishioner stood up to share a story. “She says, ‘You know, this morning, a man came over, checked my lawnmower, and pledged $1,000.’” 

For Paterson, it was another example of the generosity that has accompanied the project almost from the beginning. 

With the campaign now approximately $20,000 short of its goal, she has been encouraging parishioners to put their fundraising thermometer back on public display. 

“Get the thermometer back out there, guys. Get it out there and show them what you’ve done and how much you have left to get because it’s almost there.” 

The congregation has also drawn encouragement from its neighbours at St. Paul and St. John in Haileybury. Rev. Val says members of that church regularly ask after the people of St. James and the progress of the restoration. 

“The P.J. people are always asking me, ‘How are they doing? Are they okay? Are things coming along?’ And I said, ‘Yeah, yeah, they are. You know, they’re doing good.’” 

That quiet, consistent encouragement has mattered. 

So has the congregation’s growing confidence in its own ability to see the project through. 

A time to celebrate 

Now, after nearly a year and a half away from their worship space, the people of St. James are preparing to open their doors again. 

On November 14, the church will host its annual Christmas market, welcoming people from across the community into the building. 

Then, on Sunday, November 29, St. James will host the Parish of Northern Lights for its traditional fifth-Sunday gathering, this time with a special celebration of the church’s reopening. 

“This is definitely St. James’s time to shine,” Rev. Paterson said. “We’re going to just have a big party.” 

As of October 28, the Solid on the Rock! campaign had raised $131,900 toward its $146,000 goal, leaving just $14,100 to go. For a congregation that once struggled to fill a few pews on Sunday morning, it is a remarkable achievement—and one Paterson is determined to keep moving forward. 

There is still money to raise and work to complete. Rev. Val hopes the campaign can be wrapped up before the end of the year, although she knows that finding the right professionals for the remaining work will take time. But the congregation has already come an extraordinary distance. 

For Paterson, one of the most meaningful changes has been watching the people of St. James begin to believe that the task before them was possible. 

“I really wanted to see St. James come to the realization that they could do it. With the help of the Lord, they could do it.” She acknowledges that there were moments of doubt in the beginning, but they didn’t last. 

“The energy took over and the Spirit was there, and the Spirit kept saying, ‘Fear not.’” 

To make a donation to the Solid on the Rock! capital campaign in support of St. James Anglican Church, Cobalt, please contact parish treasurer Tina Gagnon at [email protected].